Haddi Taha

Here is the List of Cars:

Associated TC3

Associated TC4

Kyosho Fazer

Kyosho TF-5

Hotbodies Cyclone S

HPI E10

HPI Sprint 2

HSPXeme

Ofna JL10E

Tamiya TT01

Tamiya TA05

Tamiya TB03

Thundertiger Sparrow Hawk

3Racing Sakura S

Order these cars from1st to last, please rate according toValuefor Money,Durabilty, Abilty to hand Brushless, Adjustabilty, Parts Support and Race abilty (to cars of same price range)

I will add up your rankings so that the cars with the lowest points win like a game of golf.

EG.
Car X recieved rankings 4th,6th,3rd,8th,9th,3rd,2nd,9th,3rd,6th so that adds to a score of53

You may discuss the cars but don't let an arguement out of hand.




</p>

Haddi Taha

My Rating

1st Tamiya TA05
2nd Hotbodies Cyclone S
3rd Tamiya TB03
3rdAssociated TC3
5thAssociated TC4
6thHPI Sprint 2
7th 3Racing Sakura S
8th Kyosho TF-5
9th Tamiya TT01
10th Thundertiger Sparrowhawk
11th HSP Xeme
12th Ofna JL10E
13th HPI E10
14th Kyosho Fazer

My Reasons
1. The Tamiya TA05 narrowly beats the Cyclone S as you can get the TA05v.2 or the stock one whichcomes with a shell and can motor
2. I couldn'd decide between the TB03's which haves the trf416's legndary suspension design and unbelievable rear traction and the tc3 which i one of the most succesful rc touring cars and is reasonably cheap to buy compared to some of the other cars on the list.
3. The Sakura S is not as good as the other cars such as sprint 2, tc4 and TF-5 but for $100 kit and cheap spares you can't go wrong.
4. The Kyosho TF5 earnt a lower place than it's main rivls as its pricier than the other cars with better race success
5. The TT01 lacks adjustablity but is the most user friendly here if you set the spur gear assembly correct.
6. The HSP is not the best quality car but sure is great for the cash, $150 RTR
7. The Thundertiger and Ofna are great performers but lack parts support for a mean angry brushless driver.
8. The HPI E10 can't keep up with some of the other cars and has some known problems with the drivetrain.
9. Kyosho Fazer is last in my book as it has a bad part support system and doesn't looklike it will keep up on brushless.

My oppinion

Ttam Says Blarg

1.TAO5
2.Cyclone S
3.TT01
4.TB03
5.TC4
6.TC3
7.Sakura S
8.Sprint 2
9.Ofna JL10E
10. E10
11. Kyosho Fazer
12.Kyosho TF-5
13.Thundertiger Sparrowhawk
14. HSP

dragnse7en

1. Tamiya TA05
2. Hotbodies Cyclone S
3. Associated TC4
4. Associated TC3
5. Tamiya TT01
6. Tamiya TB03
7. Kyosho Fazer
8. Ofna JL10E
9. HPI E10
10. Kyosho TF-5
11. HPI Sprint 2
12. HSPXeme
13. Thundertiger Sparrow Hawk
14. 3Racing Sakura S

Anything from 3Racing from my experience is last place - just terrible quality, and one small step above a radio shack toy.

I see that none of the X Ray series cars were listed. Neither any Tamiya TRF cars. X Ray would be 1st, then any Tamiya TRF or belt driven TC. Since no TRFs were mentioned, I'd have to go with the Cyclone. A solid third for anything AE.

From the choices listed, sorry - I simply love the layout and ease of maintenance on both my TA05-R and V2 R

Haddi Taha

Thanks for the input so far, i have not included and of those cars dragnse7en because i want to rank plastic chassis cars. No need to say sorry, Tamiya TA05V.2 is a sweet ride, it will be my next project.

Haddi Taha

When we have suffiecient posts i will put the rankings up or if you want to know what we have so far:

1st TA05 3pts</p>

2nd Hotbodies Cyclone S 6pts</p>

3rd Associated TC4 12pts</p>

4th Associated TC3 13pts</p>

4th Tamiya TB03 13pts</p>

5th Tamiya TT01 16pts</p>

6th HPI Sprint 2 24pts</p>

7th 3Racing SakuraS 27pts</p>

8th Ofna Jl10E 28pts</p>

9th Kyosho TF-5 29pts</p>

10th Kyosho Fazer 31pts</p>

11th HPI E10 31pts</p>

12th Thundertiger Sparrowhawk 35pts</p>

13th HSP Xeme 36pts

Thanks again and the more posts we get the more accurate the rankings are</p>

Moontan13

Does your disdain for 3Racing cars extend to that brand of aftermarket parts for the TT01 or TA05?

Haddi Taha

I ve seen dragnse7en's ta05v.2 and it doesn't have any 3 racing products from what i see

dragnse7en

Both my cousin and I had MO-3L Mini Coopers, and bought 3Racing parts for them. Needless to say, we were both quite unhappy. Almost all the parts didn't fit correctly, and we had to mod them or alter them to get them to fit right. The only thing I liked wre the chassis connector plates. After that experience, no more 3Racing for either of us.

Yes Haddi, My TA05 Ver.2 R is 100% Tamiya and TRF Good eye !

ElectricGuy007

I say either the TA05 or TC4. Because the RTR TC4 is only $200 for a RTR car. Shell is already painted etc..
1) TA05
2) TC4

Haddi Taha

thanks electricguy007

what did you think of the other cars? If you have never heard of them then please research before you post so that we have a fair ranking.

Dragnse7en yeah i'm not a big fan of 3 racing either, however they do seem to work on my tt01e well (for looks) I have barely started hoping up my tamiya tb03 and the only 3racing i got on it are the turnbuckles, can't justify spending $150+ on turnbuckles, thats a new mamba bl system

Moontan13

Are there any non-Tamiya parts that are good?

dragnse7en

Ahh - Iforgot I have a few on my V2 R, so it's not 100% after all. Maybe 98%.

Robinson Racing 64P spur and pinion
AE springs on the rear dampers
AE lead conuter weights attached to the battery bar
Acer Racing ceramic nitiride diff balls in the rear pulley
Jaco Blues - premounted

Other non-Tamiya parts that work good are:

Kimbrough gears and servo savers
Square RC parts - if you can find them
HPI wheels - indestructable
TOPCAD parts - never heard of any complaints about those
Yeah Racing parts - same as mentioned above

Haddi Taha

are kawada gears good? yeah racing stuff are ok but i did run into trouble with there dampers, they leaked oil and you can't use ball headed screws as yeah racing had there own mounting systemwhich disturbed my ifs.

dragnse7en

Oh - Kawada . . . .

Stay away from them. Hit and miss, just like the company Integy.. I tried both their aftermarket parts for both my old TA05-R and AE TC5FT - with no luck on both. Only one side worked on both Kawada and Integy steering knuckes (hubs) but left versus right they suck.

I'm not surprised over the years that both Kawada and Integy cannot get it right, with their left versus right parts. I used to be a 3D CAD designer, and even I could get that right, but why the hell should I fix another company (in this case two companies) mistakes?

Both Kawada and Integy still have rookie CAD techs, with zero engineering support. They are both cheap companies that can't afford a real mech engineer.

I guess that's why I didn't mention both those companies here - too cheap to hire quality work.

dragnse7en

1. <u>Tamiya TA05 and V2 series</u>
2. Hotbodies Cyclone S
3. Associated TC4
4. Associated TC3
5. Tamiya TT01
6. Tamiya TB03
7. Kyosho Fazer
8. Ofna JL10E
9. HPI E10
10. Kyosho TF-5
11. HPI Sprint 2
12. HSPXeme
13. Thundertiger Sparrow Hawk
14. 3Racing Sakura S

<u>double count me on this vote, since we are off-topic</u>

Moontan13

I appreciate the info regarding parts.
The Xray T3-11 came onto my radar as another choice on the level of a TRF 416x or 417. How is the Xray company in regard to parts?

Haddi Taha

thanks for the help dragnse7en lol i was going to get the kawada spurs and put them at the wrath of my hobbywing ezrun 8.5t 3s! when i meant ta05 i meant the whole platform with the ta05, ta05ms, ta05r, ta05ifs, ta05ifs r, ta05 v.2 and ta05v.2. What brands of spurs will be ideal for brushless use? And what pitch is best for my tb03, basher and occasional racer on not very prepared ashphalt track. fully enclosed drivetrain. I am using the tamiya stock ones and i am happy with the quality but finding pinions is hard as to get around 6.0fdr for 8.5t motor i need to use 26t av pinion but i can only find 25t which puts me undergeared ,6.250fdr. One more thing, when using a 3s do i have to have smaller pinion then when using 2s or not. Thanks

dragnse7en

I believe that one of my favorite online hobby stores carries X Ray parts. Aside from that, I've heard no complaints from the T3 drivers. As far as quality, I think they're really good, and designed much better than an AE TC6. Changing the roll center and toe-in on the XRay is much faster and quite similiar to an EVOIVor EVOV series Tamiya. The AE TC6 needs to be almost completely torn apart to do the same thing.

dragnse7en

48P would be fine if you're bashing in a parking lot. I use 64P gears because I can pick from a larger range of gear ratios. All the BL guys I know use Kimbrough gears but I've used RR stuff way longer (over twenty years) and they have never let me down. 64P also seems to be quieter and I don't get any small rocks stuck in between the teeth.

I can calculate your approximate top speed for your 3S 8.5T BL car, but I will need to know what the largest spur gear size (either 64P, 48P, 48p av, no matter) that can be used on it. I also need to know your gearbox ratio. Your gearbox ratio should be this:
Diff Gear (X) divided by Counterf Gear (Y) equals gear ratio (Z)

My old TA05-R, for example, may seem to not have gearboxes per se, but the center pulleys are technically the counter gears, at 16T each. The front and rear pulleys (or diff pulleys) are 36T, so 36/16=2.25

For shaft drive cars, the counter gears are typically the ones that connect to each end of the center shaft, and drive the F and R diffs.

To get the FDR you want, you may need to step away from the AV gear pitch. I did the same to the 04 module gear pitch setup.

Oh - yeah, I'm thinking go smaller on the pinion on a 3S vs a 2S, unless you can fit a heatsink and cooling fan combo on the motor. The larger the pinion, the harder the motor has to work, and the hotter it will get.

Haddi Taha

thanks i am only bashing now so i am going to use av gears. My spur is 64t av pitch and final gear ratio is 2.44. My wheels are 60mm diameter foams. i'm buying a set of 2 pinions, av 24t and 25t. Thanks for all the help..

dragnse7en

ugghh - sorry let me check

dragnse7en

so sorry for the last posting - still checking

dragnse7en

still checking so sorry Haddi

dragnse7en

pm sent to Haddi Taha