How hot should my engine be after running?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: St Louis, MO
Posts: 1,176
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How hot should my engine be after running?
I hear a lot about preventing overheating. But how do I know what is too hot? After running my ZDZ 80, it seems hotter than my glow engines. I'm not ready to invest in a temperature gun so I would like to use some form of "touch" method?
Tom
Tom
#3
Senior Member
Re: How hot should my engine be after running?
Originally posted by greenboot
I'm not ready to invest in a temperature gun .........
I'm not ready to invest in a temperature gun .........
http://www.radioshack.com/product.as...%5Fid=22%2D325
#4
My Feedback: (44)
How hot should my engine be after running?
I second that -temperature is the killer of a gas engine so ensure you have sufficient ducting with a larger area for air to exit the cowl as opposed to entering. You should get a 'reading' of 225 or less immediatly after landing.Try to direct the temperature gun between the crank case and first cooling fins on the cylinder. Would appreciate feed back to my recommendations-
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: St Louis, MO
Posts: 1,176
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How hot should my engine be after running?
Richard,
That's the first actual number I've heard. Where did you hear it? Just wondering. I suppose you could just take a bunch of readings and use the highest one.
Tom
That's the first actual number I've heard. Where did you hear it? Just wondering. I suppose you could just take a bunch of readings and use the highest one.
Tom
#9
Member
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Santa Fe,
NM
Posts: 77
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How hot should my engine be after running?
Originally posted by JWN
Gas engines run hotter than glow. Gas burns hotter than methanol.
John
Gas engines run hotter than glow. Gas burns hotter than methanol.
John
LS
#10
Senior Member
How hot should my engine be after running?
Lucein,
You have done your homework. The only exception is where you shoot the cylinder with the laser gun. The only real way to tune an engine by temperature is by the exhaust gas temperature. I have tested the laser method a lot and found that I can get as much as 75 degrees difference between readings just depending on where the cylinder is shot. The hottest location always seem to be between the second or third fin from the top of the cylinder. The other thing is that the more effiecient the cylinder is at removing the heat the higher the reading will be.
Keith
BME
You have done your homework. The only exception is where you shoot the cylinder with the laser gun. The only real way to tune an engine by temperature is by the exhaust gas temperature. I have tested the laser method a lot and found that I can get as much as 75 degrees difference between readings just depending on where the cylinder is shot. The hottest location always seem to be between the second or third fin from the top of the cylinder. The other thing is that the more effiecient the cylinder is at removing the heat the higher the reading will be.
Keith
BME
#11
Member
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Santa Fe,
NM
Posts: 77
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How hot should my engine be after running?
Originally posted by BME
Lucein,
You have done your homework. The only exception is where you shoot the cylinder with the laser gun. The only real way to tune an engine by temperature is by the exhaust gas temperature. I have tested the laser method a lot and found that I can get as much as 75 degrees difference between readings just depending on where the cylinder is shot. The hottest location always seem to be between the second or third fin from the top of the cylinder. The other thing is that the more effiecient the cylinder is at removing the heat the higher the reading will be.
Keith
BME
Lucein,
You have done your homework. The only exception is where you shoot the cylinder with the laser gun. The only real way to tune an engine by temperature is by the exhaust gas temperature. I have tested the laser method a lot and found that I can get as much as 75 degrees difference between readings just depending on where the cylinder is shot. The hottest location always seem to be between the second or third fin from the top of the cylinder. The other thing is that the more effiecient the cylinder is at removing the heat the higher the reading will be.
Keith
BME
The big gassers that are too strong to restrain on the ground or use fixed jetting carbs are usually tuned with EGT. I'd say a good rule of thumb for most gassers is about 1000F at full throttle, but that'll probably vary from motor to motor. You want it to go down at full throttle, indicating a nice rich top end mix (our motors are primarily fuel cooled, the air cooling is pretty much only a small part of the cooling system).
Otherwise, I get the best results by setting the high speed mixture on the "knee" by manual tuning on the ground, like usual, and properly propping the motor for a good load at both full throttle and cruise.
Biggest mistake I see is running too lean or under/over propping. Underpropping is probably the worst of the two - a too unloaded of a prop in the air leads to a high rpm/low throttle opening situation which leads to unsufficient lubrication/cooling which leads to you-know-what.....
Overpropping is bad too - lugs the motor which puts a lot of stress on the moving parts, especially the bearings.
I like to run rich mixtures. Gives more carbon, but better lube and cooling. And, it doesn't hurt that motor to put out slightly less than full rated power on a continuous basis.....
LS
#12
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Hammond,
IN
Posts: 3,262
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How hot should my engine be after running?
Lucien:
I keep seeing the claim of gasoline 2-strokes being "primarily fuel cooled". That's not true, and here is the why. The Heat of Vaporization of gasoline is around 900 BTU/gallon of gas. The Lower Heating Value of gasoline is around 115,000 BTU/gallon of gas. Gasoline engines are about 30% efficient. This means that 70% of the energy of the fuel is not turned into mechanical energy, but is wasted as heat. If you burn a gallon of gas, approximately 80,000 BTU is wasted as heat and has to be removed. Only 900 BTU is available for cooling from the heat of vaporization. 79,100 BTU has to be removed by other means. This heat gets removed in 2 ways - through the cylinder fins to the air, or out the exhaust as waste heat.
Having a high heat of vaporization is valuable because it can increase the charge density of the incoming fuel air mixture which can raise the power of the engine. That's the same reason they use intercoolers on turbocharged engines. But, you wouldn't want to drain the radiator and count on the intercooler to keep the engine from overheating.
I keep seeing the claim of gasoline 2-strokes being "primarily fuel cooled". That's not true, and here is the why. The Heat of Vaporization of gasoline is around 900 BTU/gallon of gas. The Lower Heating Value of gasoline is around 115,000 BTU/gallon of gas. Gasoline engines are about 30% efficient. This means that 70% of the energy of the fuel is not turned into mechanical energy, but is wasted as heat. If you burn a gallon of gas, approximately 80,000 BTU is wasted as heat and has to be removed. Only 900 BTU is available for cooling from the heat of vaporization. 79,100 BTU has to be removed by other means. This heat gets removed in 2 ways - through the cylinder fins to the air, or out the exhaust as waste heat.
Having a high heat of vaporization is valuable because it can increase the charge density of the incoming fuel air mixture which can raise the power of the engine. That's the same reason they use intercoolers on turbocharged engines. But, you wouldn't want to drain the radiator and count on the intercooler to keep the engine from overheating.
#13
Member
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Santa Fe,
NM
Posts: 77
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How hot should my engine be after running?
Originally posted by Diablo
Lucien:
I keep seeing the claim of gasoline 2-strokes being "primarily fuel cooled". That's not true, and here is the why. The Heat of Vaporization of gasoline is around 900 BTU/gallon of gas. The Lower Heating Value of gasoline is around 115,000 BTU/gallon of gas. Gasoline engines are about 30% efficient. This means that 70% of the energy of the fuel is not turned into mechanical energy, but is wasted as heat. If you burn a gallon of gas, approximately 80,000 BTU is wasted as heat and has to be removed. Only 900 BTU is available for cooling from the heat of vaporization. 79,100 BTU has to be removed by other means. This heat gets removed in 2 ways - through the cylinder fins to the air, or out the exhaust as waste heat.
Having a high heat of vaporization is valuable because it can increase the charge density of the incoming fuel air mixture which can raise the power of the engine. That's the same reason they use intercoolers on turbocharged engines. But, you wouldn't want to drain the radiator and count on the intercooler to keep the engine from overheating.
Lucien:
I keep seeing the claim of gasoline 2-strokes being "primarily fuel cooled". That's not true, and here is the why. The Heat of Vaporization of gasoline is around 900 BTU/gallon of gas. The Lower Heating Value of gasoline is around 115,000 BTU/gallon of gas. Gasoline engines are about 30% efficient. This means that 70% of the energy of the fuel is not turned into mechanical energy, but is wasted as heat. If you burn a gallon of gas, approximately 80,000 BTU is wasted as heat and has to be removed. Only 900 BTU is available for cooling from the heat of vaporization. 79,100 BTU has to be removed by other means. This heat gets removed in 2 ways - through the cylinder fins to the air, or out the exhaust as waste heat.
Having a high heat of vaporization is valuable because it can increase the charge density of the incoming fuel air mixture which can raise the power of the engine. That's the same reason they use intercoolers on turbocharged engines. But, you wouldn't want to drain the radiator and count on the intercooler to keep the engine from overheating.
Leaving aside from the heat simply going out of the exhaust, you're left with two basic cooling systems: fuel (heat dissipation via vaporization of the fuel) and airflow over the cooling fins (in the case of an aircooled motor).
Of these two, heat dissipation through the cooling fins is by far the least effective cooling system. In particular, for the internal parts of the motor besides just the head/cylinder and outside of piston, such as the center of the piston crown, pin and bearings, and bottom end, air cooling plays a pretty miniscule role. As you know, these parts get pretty hot and the primary means of cooling them is the incoming fuel/oil charge, not air cooling.
Again, this is all apart from the matter of heat simply going out of the exhaust pipe. I'll grant that that's actually the primary means of cooling, to be really technical about it.
But for sure, fuel/oil cooling plays the most significant role in cooling a 2-stroke, particularly an aircooled one. A motor with enough cooling fin area to obviate fuel/oil cooling would be too large and heavy to be practical in an aircraft. So, a compromise is made - cooling fins are left smaller to keep size/weight down, and more emphasis is placed on cooling via the fuel. That's why we run them rich, particularly on the top end.....
LS