View Poll Results: A poll
Voters: 51. You may not vote on this poll
Electric, Nitro, or Gas
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Southern,
CA
Posts: 93
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Electric, Nitro, or Gas
Ok here's a poll, this can be your favorite, what you own, what you prefer, or what you support. No rules just vote for one. I understand that you might love them all or hate them all, but in the end you can only vote for one.
General voting with no purpose seems like it would end up in this thread spinning out of control and ultimately being locked or deleted. Game on!
General voting with no purpose seems like it would end up in this thread spinning out of control and ultimately being locked or deleted. Game on!
#2
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Owensboro, KY
Posts: 5,527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
All I own is electric, I've had bad experinces with nitro because tuning a motor is a pain in the butt.
The engine is either too rich or too lean, I can only imagine what people go through tuning 3 or more needles.[&:]
I like charging batteries.
The engine is either too rich or too lean, I can only imagine what people go through tuning 3 or more needles.[&:]
I like charging batteries.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Thousand Oaks,
CA
Posts: 8,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
i have electric and nitro and both love them, tuning is hard for the first gallon but after that it should be easier, i like nitro because its "fuel and go" while electric is "charge, charge, drive, charge charge", i do like the sheer POWER of electric motors and the ease of use and SILENCE of them[8D]
#10
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
Started with a nitro savage, moved towards electric, then went back to nitro. I find tuning very easy and quick, and I love the sound of it zooming by. Gas isn't an option because I race also.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Torchy the Fiery Fast RC Turtl
Posts: 10,544
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
With the price of nito going up by as much as 50% more, the price of $5 gasoline is much much more appealing than $30 for 20% nitro. Furthermore, gasoline has way way mroe BTUs per mas than nitro fuel will ever have. This means way way less fuel neecds to be dumped into the massive 23-35cc cylinders thann compared to what even a .12ci nitro engine does (fuel:cc ratio that is).
So, a fulie engin can sip on gas where even the tiniest nitro engine suck nitro like a whale. That is why a fulie engine will run for 20-30min on one tank of gasoline where even a .12ci nitro engine runs out of fuel in only 10-15min, even when running very very lean.
Additionally, gasoline 2-strokes are virtually mainteannce & tuning free. Tune once and that is juct about it. The break-in procedure for gasoline engines is also much more simple than that of a nitro engine. Yes, some maintenance and tuning are required, but not to the high tinkering levels of a nitro engine.
Additionally to all this, gasoline engines make WAY more torque than what the nitro engiens will ever make due to a combination of 2 things: the massive displacement advantage ofver nitro engines, and again, gasoline has way more BTUs per mass, so much more force comes from the combustion of the fuel-air charge. A nitro engine might see up to 2BHP where a 23cc gasoline engine would probably make only 1.5BHP, but that gas engine will make nearly 1.5 ft-lbs torque wehre the 2BHP nitro engine would be struggling to even make half a ft-lbf of torque. Nitro engiens might turn very very high RPMs, but the massive torques of gasoline engins allow them to be geared very very high such that they ca make op speeds similar to nitro engines.
My vote therefore goes to gasoline.
So, a fulie engin can sip on gas where even the tiniest nitro engine suck nitro like a whale. That is why a fulie engine will run for 20-30min on one tank of gasoline where even a .12ci nitro engine runs out of fuel in only 10-15min, even when running very very lean.
Additionally, gasoline 2-strokes are virtually mainteannce & tuning free. Tune once and that is juct about it. The break-in procedure for gasoline engines is also much more simple than that of a nitro engine. Yes, some maintenance and tuning are required, but not to the high tinkering levels of a nitro engine.
Additionally to all this, gasoline engines make WAY more torque than what the nitro engiens will ever make due to a combination of 2 things: the massive displacement advantage ofver nitro engines, and again, gasoline has way more BTUs per mass, so much more force comes from the combustion of the fuel-air charge. A nitro engine might see up to 2BHP where a 23cc gasoline engine would probably make only 1.5BHP, but that gas engine will make nearly 1.5 ft-lbs torque wehre the 2BHP nitro engine would be struggling to even make half a ft-lbf of torque. Nitro engiens might turn very very high RPMs, but the massive torques of gasoline engins allow them to be geared very very high such that they ca make op speeds similar to nitro engines.
My vote therefore goes to gasoline.
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Torchy the Fiery Fast RC Turtl
Posts: 10,544
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
ORIGINAL: AutoXMan
Started with a nitro savage, moved towards electric, then went back to nitro. I find tuning very easy and quick, and I love the sound of it zooming by. Gas isn't an option because I race also.
Started with a nitro savage, moved towards electric, then went back to nitro. I find tuning very easy and quick, and I love the sound of it zooming by. Gas isn't an option because I race also.
#15
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Torchy the Fiery Fast RC Turtl
Posts: 10,544
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
A 5th scale fulie is next on my list, pref a 4WD. I dont know what route I am going to take, but if someone winds up selling a used one, I will go that route, rebuild or replace the engine, and go from there. Much better than killing my wallet by paying the rediculous $1000+ inflated prices. Weedeaters cost $100USD or less, why cant the gas RCs be more affordable too? For 99% of our RC being made very very cheaply in china, the saving should be passed on to the purchaser. Someone in between the factory and the retailer is getting way too much money. Yes, R&D is not cheap, but there is no way that R&D, overhead, shipping, middlemen, etc. cost more than 50% of shelf price. Worse, has anyone seen the MSRP of RCs? For example, I believe HPI suggest a sale price of $700-$800 for the Savage XL! No wonder all the guys from distribution to the retailer chop the price down to the 500's.
#17
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Owensboro, KY
Posts: 5,527
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
ORIGINAL: SAVAGEJIM
Too bad the RC wold does not have a gas class. If they were to start one, I gaurantee many more fans will cough up $1000+ USD to buy gas RCs and race them. Heck, many RCs, even electric ones, can exceed $1000 USD with all the aftermarket options and hop-ups put in them.
ORIGINAL: AutoXMan
Started with a nitro savage, moved towards electric, then went back to nitro. I find tuning very easy and quick, and I love the sound of it zooming by. Gas isn't an option because I race also.
Started with a nitro savage, moved towards electric, then went back to nitro. I find tuning very easy and quick, and I love the sound of it zooming by. Gas isn't an option because I race also.
#19
Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: fontana, CA
Posts: 43
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
ORIGINAL: Pathous
I like nitro but I have seen some very impresive electric. I find most engines are easy to tune.
I like nitro but I have seen some very impresive electric. I find most engines are easy to tune.
#22
RE: Electric, Nitro, or Gas
I own (1) nitro and (1) gas. No electric. I don't like electric. The only noise they make is gear whine. Gotta' have internal combustion to make me happy. My nitro is the Losi XXX-NT AD2 and my gas is the HPI Baja B5 SS kit.